PGC NEWS

The Black Death. A devastating plague that swept across Europe, leaving a trail of death and despair. A Plague Tale: Innocence throws players into the heart of this dark period, following the harrowing journey of Amicia and Hugo de Rune, two noble children forced to navigate a world consumed by disease, rats, and the Inquisition. This review explores the game’s strengths and weaknesses, examining its powerful narrative alongside its somewhat limiting gameplay.

A Descent into Darkness

Amicia and Hugo’s story begins abruptly, their privileged lives shattered by the sudden arrival of the plague. The siblings find themselves thrust into a nightmare, surrounded by the carnage of both animals and humans. The atmosphere is thick with dread, the constant threat of the Inquisition and the horrifying swarms of rats creating a palpable sense of tension. Amicia, the elder sister, must protect her frail younger brother, Hugo, as they flee their home and venture into the unknown.

A Plague Tale: Innocence

The bond between Amicia and Hugo forms the emotional core of the game. Their relationship, initially strained by their different upbringings, evolves organically throughout their ordeal. Small gestures, like Hugo picking flowers for Amicia, add a touch of humanity to their grim circumstances. These moments of tenderness highlight the innocence that the game’s title suggests, serving as a stark contrast to the surrounding darkness.

A Plague Tale: Innocence

While the overall narrative is compelling, it isn’t without its flaws. The plot is somewhat predictable, lacking major twists or surprises. Certain characters feel underdeveloped, their motivations lacking depth. However, the game’s powerful depiction of the plague and its impact on the characters remains its most striking achievement.

Leading the Rats

Despite its strong narrative focus, A Plague Tale: Innocence falters in its gameplay. The game strives to portray the vulnerability of a 15-year-old girl in a hostile world, but its mechanics often undermine this intention. Amicia’s slingshot, initially intended as a tool for lighting torches and distracting rats, becomes a surprisingly effective weapon against armored guards.

A Plague Tale: Innocence

The gameplay loop often feels overly simplistic. The fearsome rats, the game’s central threat, are easily manipulated with fire. The level design rarely presents a genuine challenge, with solutions often readily apparent. Resources are conveniently placed, eliminating the need for strategic thinking or exploration.

The puzzle elements often feel too straightforward, diminishing the sense of danger.

Furthermore, the “escorting child” mechanic feels largely superficial. While Hugo’s presence is constant, he rarely impacts the gameplay in a meaningful way. Amicia’s interactions with him are limited, reducing their relationship to a narrative element rather than an integral part of the game’s mechanics.

Hugo’s presence in the game often feels more symbolic than impactful.

A Missed Opportunity

A Plague Tale: Innocence presents a compelling story of survival and sibling bonds against a backdrop of historical tragedy. However, its simplistic gameplay and underutilized mechanics prevent it from fully realizing its potential. The game’s linear progression and overly obvious solutions detract from the sense of danger and urgency that the narrative so effectively establishes.

A Plague Tale: Innocence

In conclusion, A Plague Tale: Innocence is a game of contrasts. Its gripping narrative and evocative atmosphere are weighed down by its predictable plot and simplistic gameplay. While the game successfully portrays the horrors of the plague and the strength of familial bonds, it ultimately falls short of delivering a truly engaging and challenging gameplay experience.