PGC NEWS

The Walking Dead: A New Frontier had a rocky start but seemed to find its footing in episode two, introducing a familiar yet new character and ending with a shocking twist. However, episode three, Above the Law, stumbles once more, presenting a disjointed, directionless narrative that feels largely on autopilot. Let’s delve into the strengths and weaknesses of this latest installment.

Clementine and AJ’s Enduring Narrative

One of the primary reasons to stick with A New Frontier is the continuing story of Clementine and AJ. Clementine, no longer the vulnerable child of season one, has become a protector, echoing the influence of Lee Everett. Any doubts lingering from the previous two episodes about whether this is truly the same Clementine are dispelled here, as the episode provides valuable insight into her hardened demeanor. Witnessing her growth and the complex relationship she develops with AJ is a compelling narrative thread.

Clementine and AJ

Javier and the Return of David

Another bright spot is Javier’s storyline, further enriched by the unexpected return of his brother, David. Presumed dead, David resurfaces in The New Frontier in a new role. Refreshingly, the game avoids portraying him as purely good or evil. His interactions with Javier, Kate, and Gabriel reveal a complex character, suggesting he might be a valuable, albeit temporary, ally in this brutal world.

Tense Encounter

A Disappointing Lack of Depth

Unfortunately, these are the only significant positives. Above the Law showcases some of Telltale Games’ worst tendencies. The dialogue is weak, filled with bland, perfunctory lines that make the voice acting feel detached and unconvincing. This issue, noticeable in previous Telltale titles, reaches a new low here. The narrative also suffers from predictability. The sudden departure of Jesus feels contrived and echoes similar character exits in past seasons. The Richmond community, led by power-hungry individuals, retreads familiar ground. Even the antagonist’s speeches about survival in a harsh world feel tired and clichéd.

Confrontation

Perhaps most disappointing is the lack of interactivity. There’s a single, brief segment allowing player control of Javier, lasting mere seconds. The quick-time events offer nothing new, and the overall experience feels passive. Waiting three months for a 50-minute episode that plays itself is unacceptable, even by Telltale’s standards.

Conclusion

While Clementine and AJ’s story, coupled with Javier’s complex relationship with David, provides some engaging moments, Above the Law ultimately falls short. The weak dialogue, predictable plot, and minimal interactivity make it a frustrating experience. The episode hints at potential, but the execution leaves much to be desired. Hopefully, future installments will address these shortcomings and deliver a more compelling and interactive experience.