PGC NEWS

The Souls-like genre, popularized by FromSoftware, has become a coveted formula for action RPG developers. However, harmonizing the core tenets of Souls games with original ideas is a challenging feat, especially for less experienced studios. A44 Games, the developers of Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn, attempt this delicate balance with their self-proclaimed “Souls-lite” offering. Does Flintlock deliver on its potential, or does it fall short of the mark?

alt text describing image of combat with axe and gun

A Thrilling Blend of Gunpowder, Steel, and Magic

Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn transports players to a unique setting where gunpowder technology has revolutionized warfare. Players control Nor Vanek, a skilled gunslinger and melee combatant, fighting alongside her fox-like companion, Enki, a powerful magic-wielding god. This combination of weaponry and magic creates a dynamic combat system that feels both familiar and refreshingly new.

The combat blends the frenetic energy of God of War with the strategic gunplay of Bloodborne, further enhanced by Enki’s magical abilities. Unlike other Souls-like titles, Flintlock tightly integrates ranged and melee combat. Guns are not optional but essential for breaking enemy armor, creating openings for devastating melee attacks.

alt text describing image of companion Enki using magic

Enki’s “curse” mechanic adds another layer to the combat. By cursing enemies, Nor can amplify her damage and stagger them, creating opportunities for critical hits. This interplay between guns, melee weapons, and magic creates a satisfyingly complex combat loop. Each encounter demands careful positioning, timing, and resource management, culminating in cinematic slow-motion finishers that reward skillful play.

A robust skill tree further expands combat options, allowing Nor to unlock powerful combinations and enhance Enki’s support abilities. The freedom of movement, including double jumps, dodges, and dashes, adds to the fluidity of combat, allowing for creative approaches to enemy encounters.

alt text describing image of melee combat against multiple enemies

A Wasted Potential: Narrative Shortcomings and Design Flaws

Despite the promising combat system, Flintlock stumbles significantly in its narrative and world design. The story is disappointingly linear and predictable, lacking the depth and complexity expected from a Souls-like experience. The game’s semi-open world offers little incentive for exploration, with a single, obvious path leading from one boss encounter to the next.

The plot itself is thin, with underdeveloped characters and poorly explained motivations. Key plot points are glossed over, leaving players with unanswered questions. The dialogue often feels forced and unnatural, failing to create genuine emotional connections between Nor and Enki or to provide compelling context for the world’s events.

alt text describing image of the game's environment

The world design also suffers from a lack of depth. While visually appealing in some areas, the environments often feel lifeless and lacking in interactive elements. The rewards for exploration are meager, with many items feeling redundant or useless. The game’s economy is poorly balanced, making it easy to acquire powerful upgrades early on, further diminishing the incentive to explore.

alt text describing image of character screen with skill tree

Side quests are equally underwhelming, offering little narrative value or meaningful rewards. NPCs are mostly static and non-interactive, contributing little to the world’s sense of life and immersion. Even the boss encounters, a crucial element of the Souls-like genre, are disappointingly simplistic and repetitive. Most bosses are just reskinned versions of regular enemies, lacking unique mechanics or challenging patterns.

alt text describing image of environment with large crystals

A Mixed Bag: Technical Performance and Presentation

Flintlock’s technical performance is a mixed bag. The visuals are generally impressive, with detailed character models and striking environments. However, the world lacks a consistent artistic vision, with some areas feeling significantly less polished than others. The sound design is similarly uneven, with excellent voice acting and impactful combat sounds hampered by a forgettable soundtrack and poor environmental audio.

alt text describing image of the character standing in a desert environment

Conclusion

Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn shows flashes of brilliance with its innovative combat system, but ultimately falls short due to a weak narrative, underdeveloped world, and repetitive gameplay. While the core combat loop is engaging and satisfying, the surrounding elements fail to create a compelling and immersive experience. Flintlock had the potential to be a standout Souls-like title, but its flaws ultimately hold it back.

alt text describing image of character using magic in combat

alt text describing image of combat against a large enemy

alt text describing image of character inspecting a weapon

alt text describing image of character firing a gun in combat