PGC NEWS

The allure of the underworld has always captivated storytellers, weaving tales of intrigue, action, romance, and tragedy. Games are no exception, with titles like Mafia, Watch Dogs, and Grand Theft Auto V offering compelling narratives and vivid depictions of criminal empires. Empire of Sin, from legendary game designer John Romero and Romero Games, attempts a fresh take on the genre, blending strategy and turn-based RPG elements. Does it live up to the legacy of its creator?

A Strong First Impression

Empire of Sin initially impresses with its visuals, sound, and gameplay. Built on the Unity engine, the game delivers smooth performance and highly detailed models. The setting, 1920s Chicago during the Prohibition era, is meticulously recreated, capturing the city’s chaotic blend of old and new, various immigrant communities, and distinct architectural styles. Character animations, from subtle smirks to dramatic gestures, are surprisingly detailed for a non-action-focused game. While the Unity engine’s limitations are apparent in the somewhat basic dynamic lighting and explosion effects, these shortcomings are easily overlooked, given the game’s predominantly indoor, low-intensity combat scenarios.

Empire of Sin – Al Capone Character

The audio design is equally impressive, particularly the voice acting. Dialogue is well-written and delivered with a noir-ish flair that perfectly complements the game’s setting. This attention to detail highlights the Romero’s commitment to quality, even with a smaller studio’s resources.

Empire of Sin – Combat Scene

The gameplay is a unique blend of strategy and turn-based RPG. As a crime boss, you manage your territory, engaging in illicit activities, expanding your influence, and hiring goons. The game offers a diverse cast of historical figures, each with unique traits and bonuses. You’ll focus on maximizing profits, upgrading establishments, and strategically competing with rival gangs. The ultimate goal is to dominate Chicago’s underworld.

Empire of Sin – Management Screen

Managing your empire involves numerous decisions and tracking various statistics. However, the streamlined interface makes the process surprisingly accessible, akin to a casual mobile simulation game. Maintaining relationships with your underlings is crucial. Keeping them satisfied and loyal directly impacts their combat effectiveness. Disgruntled goons might abandon you, or worse, switch sides mid-battle.

When diplomacy fails, combat takes center stage. Empire of Sin features X-COM-style turn-based squad battles. Each character has limited action points, utilizes various weapons and abilities, and can take cover. Strategic positioning and coordinating attacks are key to maximizing damage. Loot, experience points, and level-ups unlock new skills, enriching your tactical options.

Empire of Sin – Combat Scene with Cover

The game includes main and side missions, shaped by your dialogue choices and negotiations with rivals. These missions guide your empire’s growth and form a cohesive narrative, reminiscent of traditional RPGs. Random events, such as rival gang attacks, police raids, and even court cases, add further depth and variety.

A Flawed Narrative

Despite its promising start, Empire of Sin falters as the gameplay loop becomes repetitive and predictable. The supporting characters, though numerous, lack depth and distinct personalities. Dialogue feels generic, lacking the nuance and impactful choices found in more compelling RPGs. The management system, initially engaging, eventually loses its significance. Combat often becomes the simplest solution, rendering economic management less crucial.

Empire of Sin – Gangster with Gun

The game’s biggest flaw is its weak narrative. Despite its rich setting and wealth of historical material, Empire of Sin fails to deliver a compelling and insightful story. The lack of narrative depth undermines the innovative gameplay, preventing the game from reaching its full potential.

Empire of Sin – City Overview

Conclusion

Empire of Sin offers a unique and initially engaging blend of strategy and RPG elements, brought to life in a meticulously crafted 1920s Chicago setting. However, its repetitive gameplay loop and, most importantly, its weak narrative prevent it from achieving greatness. While it possesses several redeeming qualities, Empire of Sin ultimately falls short of its potential, settling into the realm of a decent but ultimately forgettable experience.