PGC NEWS

The gaming industry has seen a resurgence of classic titles remastered or remade for modern platforms. This trend has sparked mixed reactions, with some celebrating the revival of beloved games and others criticizing the practice as a cash grab. Mafia: Definitive Edition, a complete remake of the 2002 classic Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven, falls squarely into this debate. Developed by Hangar 13 and published by 2K, this reimagining promises a fresh take on the familiar story of Thomas Angelo’s rise through the Salieri crime family. But does it live up to the legacy of the original, or does it lose something in the process of modernization?

A Familiar Tale, Retold

Mafia: Definitive Edition – Tommy AngeloAlt: Tommy Angelo sits in a dimly lit restaurant, his face etched with concern.

The game opens with a now-iconic scene: a middle-aged man enters a restaurant to meet a mysterious figure. Fans of the original will recognize this as the encounter between Detective Norman and Thomas Angelo, though the roles are reversed in this version. This subtle change hints at Hangar 13’s approach to the remake: retelling a familiar story from a fresh perspective. Throughout the 20 missions, new details and expanded storylines flesh out the narrative, adding depth to Thomas’s descent into the criminal underworld. These additions don’t feel forced; instead, they enhance the experience for both newcomers and veterans alike.

Hangar 13 completely overhauled the dialogue and added cinematic camera angles, giving the game a distinct movie-like feel. Facial motion capture technology brings conversations to life, conveying the characters’ emotions with impressive detail. A furrowed brow from Don Salieri hints at his cunning calculations, while Thomas’s conflicted expressions reveal his lingering moral compass. The result is an immersive experience that pulls players into the complex and captivating world of 1930s organized crime.

Mafia: Definitive Edition – Don SalieriAlt: Don Salieri, with a stern expression, addresses Tommy Angelo in a smoky back room.

Lost Heaven, the game’s fictional city, has been painstakingly recreated in stunning detail. The vibrant cityscape, complete with realistic weather effects, surpasses even the visuals of Mafia 3’s New Bordeaux. From the bustling streets to the dimly lit back alleys, Lost Heaven is arguably one of the most visually impressive open-world environments in gaming today.

Modernized Gameplay, Mixed Results

Mafia: Definitive Edition – GunfightAlt: Tommy Angelo takes cover behind a car, exchanging fire with rival gangsters in a tense street shootout.

The combat system has been updated to resemble Mafia 3, with faster-paced gunfights and more aggressive enemies. Thomas can now utilize stealth takedowns and finish off weakened opponents. These gameplay enhancements, combined with the expanded story, provide ample opportunities for exciting action sequences. However, while the original’s gunplay was limited by the technology of its time, the remake’s modernization comes at a cost.

Mafia: Definitive Edition – Car ChaseAlt: Tommy Angelo speeds through the streets of Lost Heaven in a classic car, pursued by rival gangsters.

The linear mission structure, while ensuring a tight narrative, limits the open-world freedom found in games like Grand Theft Auto V. The redesigned chase sequences, in particular, feel overly scripted and repetitive. Rather than relying on skillful driving, players are often guided to predetermined locations where obstacles conveniently stop pursuers. This simplification detracts from the challenge and excitement of the chases.

A Trade-Off in Tone and Atmosphere

Mafia: Definitive Edition – Tommy, Sam, and PaulieAlt: Tommy Angelo, Sam, and Paulie share a tense moment inside a car, the city lights reflecting in the windshield.

While the cinematic approach adds a layer of polish, it also accelerates the game’s pacing, shortening dialogue sequences and rushing through character interactions. This faster pace sacrifices the deliberate, contemplative atmosphere of the original, which allowed players to soak in the nuances of the criminal underworld. The added banter between Tommy, Sam, and Paulie, while intended to build camaraderie, sometimes feels out of character and clashes with the more serious tone of the story.

Mafia: Definitive Edition – CityscapeAlt: A panoramic view of Lost Heaven showcases the city’s architecture and bustling streets, bathed in the warm glow of the setting sun.

Even the soundtrack, while featuring period-appropriate jazz music, lacks the emotional depth and dynamism of the original score. The loading screens, which once displayed symbolic items related to each mission, have been replaced with a generic loading bar, further diminishing the game’s unique charm.

Conclusion: A Worthy Remake, But Not Without Flaws

Mafia: Definitive Edition – Rainy StreetAlt: Rain slicks the streets of Lost Heaven as pedestrians hurry along the sidewalks, the city’s neon signs reflecting in the puddles.

Mafia: Definitive Edition is a visually stunning and narratively enhanced remake that successfully modernizes a classic. However, in its pursuit of modernization, it sacrifices some of the original’s unique charm and atmosphere. The faster pacing, simplified gameplay elements, and less evocative soundtrack may disappoint purists. Ultimately, whether this remake is a success depends on what players value most. If you prioritize updated graphics and expanded storytelling, you’ll likely enjoy this reimagining. But if you cherish the original’s slower pace, atmospheric depth, and distinct personality, you may find yourself longing for the classic experience.

Mafia: Definitive Edition – Hotel ExteriorAlt: The grand exterior of a Lost Heaven hotel, its entrance bustling with activity, stands as a testament to the city’s opulence.