PGC NEWS

Monochroma, a puzzle-platformer developed by Turkish studio Nowhere Studios, draws inevitable comparisons to the critically acclaimed Limbo. Sharing a similar monochromatic aesthetic and a focus on atmospheric storytelling, Monochroma attempts to carve its own niche within the genre by introducing a unique gameplay mechanic: a younger brother who must be carried throughout the game. But does this addition elevate the experience, or does it weigh the game down?

alt text: Monochroma screenshot showing the older brother carrying the younger brother through a dark industrial environment

A World Shrouded in Shadow

Set in the 1950s, Monochroma paints a bleak picture of a post-World War II industrial society. Giant factories dominate the landscape, spewing black smoke that obscures the sky, leaving only faint glimmers of light to illuminate the path forward. Players assume the role of an older brother who, after his younger sibling suffers an accident, must navigate this dystopian world in search of help. This journey unveils a sinister conspiracy lurking within the abandoned factories.

alt text: Monochroma gameplay screenshot showcasing the game's black, white, and red color palette

The game’s limited color palette, primarily black, white, and red, effectively captures the somber atmosphere of a bygone industrial era. The visuals, while not graphically impressive, contribute to a sense of unease and foreboding. Without relying on dialogue or overt emotional displays, Monochroma conveys the powerful bond between the two brothers, their love a flickering flame against the darkness.

alt text: Monochroma environment screenshot highlighting the industrial setting

The Burden of Brotherhood

The younger brother, initially a sympathetic figure, quickly becomes a source of frustration. While the concept of carrying a dependent adds a layer of complexity to the puzzles, it often feels more like a hindrance than an enhancement. Navigating the environment becomes cumbersome, especially during chase sequences, and many puzzles require leaving the younger brother in designated light sources, adding another layer of challenge.

alt text: Monochroma gameplay screenshot demonstrating the puzzle-solving aspect of the game

While Monochroma’s puzzles are challenging, frequent checkpoints prevent excessive backtracking after inevitable mistakes. However, the brother’s presence can transform seemingly simple tasks into frustrating ordeals. He often prefers to be placed in precarious positions, adding an unnecessary layer of difficulty to already demanding puzzles.

alt text: Monochroma gameplay screenshot showing the interaction between the brothers

Technical Shortcomings

Monochroma’s control scheme is a significant detriment to the gameplay experience. Character movement feels clunky, and basic actions like climbing, pushing, and pulling are slow and unresponsive. This is compounded by puzzles requiring precise timing and positioning, making minor errors incredibly punishing.

alt text: Monochroma environment screenshot displaying the dark and gritty art style

Despite the simplistic graphics, Monochroma suffers from lengthy loading times, often presenting players with an extended black screen. Even more frustrating are the unexpected loading screens that interrupt gameplay, breaking the flow and immersion.

alt text: Monochroma screenshot showcasing the game's platforming elements

alt text: Monochroma environment screenshot depicting the desolate industrial setting

alt text: Monochroma gameplay screenshot illustrating a puzzle involving machinery

Conclusion

Monochroma presents a compelling narrative and atmosphere, but its flawed execution ultimately undermines its potential. While the younger brother mechanic adds a unique element to the gameplay, it’s poorly implemented and often detracts from the experience. Coupled with clunky controls and technical issues, Monochroma falls short of its ambition. While it offers glimpses of brilliance, its flaws prevent it from truly escaping the shadow of its inspirations.