PGC NEWS

Stronghold Crusader, released over a decade ago, remains a beloved real-time strategy (RTS) classic. Twelve years later, Firefly Studios launched Stronghold Crusader 2, aiming to reignite the passion for this historical franchise. Does this sequel recapture the magic of the original, or does it crumble under the weight of expectation? Let’s delve into the strengths and weaknesses of Stronghold Crusader 2.

A Familiar Foundation

Stronghold Crusader 2 Gameplay

Veteran players of the original Stronghold Crusader will instantly feel at home with the sequel. The core gameplay mechanics, focused on the Crusades and the struggle for the Holy Land between European and Middle Eastern forces, remain largely unchanged. The familiar campaign, skirmish, multiplayer, and castle sandbox modes offer a traditional RTS experience with some welcome upgrades. The game retains the series’ signature blend of economic simulation and military strategy, setting it apart from other RTS titles like Age of Empires. Newcomers will also find the game accessible, with the campaign mode providing a gentle introduction to the core mechanics.

Stronghold Crusader 2 Desert Environment

The immersive atmosphere of the original game is faithfully recreated in Stronghold Crusader 2. The scorching deserts of the Middle East are juxtaposed with vibrant oases, creating a visually striking and thematically appropriate backdrop for the conflict. Managing your kingdom’s economy remains a crucial aspect of gameplay, requiring careful balancing of resources, population happiness, and tax rates. The multi-step production chains, such as forging weapons before recruiting soldiers and processing food, add depth to the economic simulation.

Stronghold Crusader 2 Siege Warfare

Notable Improvements

Stronghold Crusader 2 introduces several new features to enhance the gameplay. Environmental events, such as locust plagues that impact food production and sandstorms that disrupt battles, add an element of unpredictability. Fortifications have received significant attention, with walls now supporting a variety of traps to bolster defenses. Resource gathering has been streamlined, making the process more efficient. New resources, unit types, and buildings add variety to the gameplay, though their impact is somewhat limited. Melee combat, a weak point in the original, has been improved, offering more engaging and visually dynamic battles.

Shortcomings and Frustrations

Stronghold Crusader 2 Siege Defense

Despite the improvements, Stronghold Crusader 2 suffers from some significant flaws. Siege warfare feels unbalanced, with siege engines easily overwhelming even the most fortified castles. The lack of significant differentiation between factions makes matches feel repetitive. The Swordsman unit is overpowered, dominating melee combat and overshadowing other unit types. This imbalance reduces the strategic depth of battles, promoting brute force over tactical maneuvering.

Stronghold Crusader 2 Battle Scene

The economic system also presents some issues. Building costs increase as you build closer to the keep, forcing players to expand further outward and making their settlements more vulnerable to attack. Managing population needs can be challenging, with food consumption outpacing production even with a robust economy.

Stronghold Crusader 2 Close-up of Buildings

Graphically, Stronghold Crusader 2 is a noticeable improvement over the original, but it still looks dated. The environments lack detail, and the destruction physics are underwhelming. While the lighting and shadow effects are well-implemented, they don’t compensate for the overall lack of visual polish.

Stronghold Crusader 2 Environment

Conclusion

Stronghold Crusader 2 delivers a nostalgic RTS experience with familiar gameplay and some welcome improvements. However, its unbalanced combat, dated graphics, and economic quirks prevent it from reaching its full potential. While fans of the original will find enjoyment in revisiting the Crusades, the sequel falls short of being a true successor to the throne.